Certainly the HOA has duty to treat all homeowners equally. It seems that either both or neither of the homeowners had the right to the data. Nevertheless, these issues can be complicated and factually dependent. We represent homeowners against HOAs, if you want to enforce your rights you should contact us to schedule a free case assessment with one of our attorneys. You can schedule a free case assessment 24/7 by calling 303-338-2365 or online here. At your appointment, we’ll meet by phone or video (Zoom), we’ll discuss your concerns, desired results, rights, remedies, the law, the process, timeline, how we can help, costs, etc.